Bring Debate to Your School. Explore Our 2026–2027 Programs.Explore School Programs →
American Debate League logo
Judging Guidelines

Public Forum Judging Guidelines

This page helps a judge prepare, follow a round, evaluate arguments, and complete a ballot. Exact speech times, scoring scales, evidence rules, and disclosure procedures follow official tournament instructions.

Walkthrough

How to Judge a Public Forum Round

Five steps from preparation to feedback. Each diagram has a text equivalent so it's readable on any device.

1

Before the round

Review the tournament's current rules, resolution, division, ballot, timing procedures, and conflict-of-interest requirements. Learn the speech order and any local rules that apply to this event.

Preparation checklist

RulesResolutionDivisionBallotTimingConflicts
2

Follow the round

Track each side's main claims, supporting evidence, and responses. Listen fairly rather than substituting your personal opinions for the arguments presented.

Two-column flow

Side ASide B
3

Evaluate the arguments

Identify the key disagreements and explain which side better supports and compares its arguments under the event's judging instructions. Do not choose a winner for confidence, accent, or agreement with your own views.

Claim → Evidence → Response → Comparison

ClaimEvidenceResponseComparison
4

Complete the ballot

Record the winning team, a clear reason for your decision, and speaker points per the tournament's actual scale. Verify your ballot before submitting.

Sample ballot

WinnerReasonSpeaker scoresSubmit
5

Give useful feedback

Name a strength and one specific improvement for each team, respectfully and when tournament procedures allow.

Strength / Next Step

StrengthNext step

Round Structure

Public Forum Round Order

A typical speech order. Exact times and side order follow the official tournament instructions.

  1. 1

    Team A first constructive

    Opening case and main arguments

  2. 2

    Team B first constructive

    Opening case and main arguments

  3. 3

    Crossfire (first speakers)

    Opposing first speakers question each other

  4. 4

    Team A rebuttal

    Responses to the opposing case

  5. 5

    Team B rebuttal

    Responses to the opposing case

  6. 6

    Crossfire (second speakers)

    Opposing second speakers question each other

  7. 7

    Team A summary

    Crystallizes the key arguments

  8. 8

    Team B summary

    Crystallizes the key arguments

  9. 9

    Grand crossfire (all four debaters)

    All four debaters question each other

  10. 10

    Team A final focus

    Closing comparison of why your side wins

  11. 11

    Team B final focus

    Closing comparison of why your side wins

Glossary

Key Terms

Plain-language definitions for terms you'll hear in a Public Forum round.

Case

A side's organized set of arguments for (or against) the resolution.

Rebuttal

Direct response to an opponent's argument, showing why it fails or matters less.

Crossfire

A timed question-and-answer exchange between opposing speakers.

Summary

A speech that narrows the round to the most important arguments for each side.

Final focus

The closing speech where each side explains why they won the key arguments.

Get Started

Questions about judging?

Tournament staff and the ADL team can help with ballots, rules, or technical issues.